[hanging gallow]

Originally Posted by Neverknowndragon

That what i am saying
ZELDA NOT A RPG SORRY it is close

and i know about zelda-infinite.com

I was stating it for Noreal and to clear it up a bit.

How is it not an RPG - as well why would spike tv list it as an rpg?

Actually why is it always listed as an rpg game wherever you look for it?

If we have to get technical then I'll just call it something like "storylike game" where it actually has a full complete plot with a purpose other than taking out thugs on the street, or running on some mission to shoot some in the head, or even more just to completly jab little squares into a certain position so they fit nicely.

[Neverknowndragon]

Originally Posted by hanging gallow

I was stating it for Noreal and to clear it up a bit.

How is it not an RPG - as well why would spike tv list it as an rpg?

Actually why is it always listed as an rpg game wherever you look for it?

If we have to get technical then I'll just call it something like "storylike game" where it actually has a full complete plot with a purpose other than taking out thugs on the street, or running on some mission to shoot some in the head, or even more just to completly jab little squares into a certain position so they fit nicely.

Nintento says it not a RPG for one and it just has certain elements of a Rpg

[Charchar]

<_<; I'm surprised someone would think that Zelda is not an rpg.
If it's not, what would it be then?
I can't imagine what other genre or type it would be.

Anywhow, I have never thought of the relationship of mangas to videogames. >_<;
I've never based it off of that, although they do have games that are based off of mangas.
(I can't think of a title right now though. >.<;

[Neverknowndragon]

Originally Posted by charchar1

<_<; I'm surprised someone would think that Zelda is not an rpg.
If it's not, what would it be then?
I can't imagine what other genre or type it would be.

Anywhow, I have never thought of the relationship of mangas to videogames. >_<;
I've never based it off of that, although they do have games that are based off of mangas.
(I can't think of a title right now though. >.<;

'

Nintendo and it creator have state many times that it is not a rpg it is action adventure

[hanging gallow]

So now Nintendo has to get technical

So what if they state its not an rpg, its still an rpg based game in my world and I'm sure in alot of other worlds

It still is everywhere else except for Nintendo

edit: I wouldn't be surprised if they stated it to keep it from having any problems with other companies such as squarenix

[Charchar]

>_<; I've kinda thought action adventure and RPG was kind of the same thing?

Am I wrong?

[Neverknowndragon]

Originally Posted by charchar1

>_<; I've kinda thought action adventure and RPG was kind of the same thing?

Am I wrong?

They are close to each other now lets stop this we all have are opinions and we think what we want to think

[hanging gallow]

Originally Posted by charchar1

>_<; I've kinda thought action adventure and RPG was kind of the same thing?

Am I wrong?

Actually I'm going to end it

She is somewhat right,

Action Adventure games have always been called RPG by gamers simply because that is what we coined it to be. Who wants to say Action Adventure when you can just say RPG. They are usually called RPG based games, because the orginal idea of an action adventure game started with rpgs.

An RPG isn't a video game, actually there is no such thing atm (unless dnd has created something that I don't know about) of an rpg game.

An rpg game is a game that you play with sets of die (or dice) in which a group of people are set together with papers, pencils, legends, maps, etc, and they actions are created by the user, usually with a set of rolls. A GM otherwise known as Game Master controls the area, settings, monsters, and etc. of the game. He or she can pretty much controls the surrondings of your character as well what you run into.

DND or otherwise known as Dungeon and Dragons is a large RPG game. You can buy sets of books online to specifications of how to set up worlds, characters, races, weapons, and etc.

Games such as Final Fantasy, Legend of Zelda, even Persona are labled as rpg based games or action adventure game, however they are not technically an rpg game.

That is why Nintendo argues that it is not an rpg game.

Edit: The closes thing to an actual rpg game would be FF 11 simply because you chose the class of your character, name, race and etc.

[kagetora01]

Originally Posted by charchar1

>_<; I've kinda thought action adventure and RPG was kind of the same thing?

Am I wrong?

i think Action adventure is when you attack the monster and the same time you can move freely... like Kingdom Hearts... while RPG is using push botton to attack and you can't move freely...like Final Fantasy..

[hanging gallow]

Originally Posted by kagetora01

i think Action adventure is when you attack the monster and the same time you can move freely... like Kingdom Hearts... while RPG is using push botton to attack and you can't move freely...like Final Fantasy..

Actually FF 12 changed that, you can run freely around now while being attacked ^_^