[haruka.hayase]

I prefer the J version too more funny and nature also lot of handsome guys especially Shirota Yuu as Kagurazaka

[justfaye]

actually the taiwanese version was more of the manga adaptation (minus the ending... i didnt like it at all!) it made me like that too but my favorite is still the japanese version... great actors and good changes in the story... funny, dramatic and romantic!

[Raisekai]

The japanese version was more unrealistic.. i mean you could immediately tell that she was a GIRL!! the tawainese was kinda manly thats why i like the japanese version better...

[reichan27]

The taiwanese version is a very funny one, Ella and Wu Zun especially Jiro Wang made a very strong impact on me,....I can't help but laugh at their funny moments...but the ending is kinda disappointing....The ending and the part where ReiXi's friend Julia ended up dating Jiro Wang is a big surprise..luckily they look cute together...oops...didn't see that coming.....On the Japanese version..I like it because unlike the taiwanese version..most of the episodes involve the 3 dorm groups....funny and very lively....but some parts of the stories were revised..but oh well...I really had fun watching the 2 versions of Hana kimi! Hope there'll be Hana Kimi '2'

[Life]

I'm probably one of the few people that likedthe taiwanese version =___=; But that's because it followed the manga more and Ella did an excellent job looking like a boy xD But her actions were so exaggerated and whenever I paused on her face I would end up cringing
I agreed that the ending was kind of disappointing, I had to suck it up and watch it since it kind of bored me to death the first half. The second half was random but funny as hell although I didn't like how it turned out.

[Secret.Wings]

I like the Taiwanese version better. Though I have to admit, Ella was exeggarated and the ending just sucked, but it was more realistic. At least, Ella looked a bit like a boy. -.-'

[moonbrat12]

Have to say I Iike the jap version better..I loved the way they changed it up. You really could get a sense of who Sano was in it. Rather then only focusing on the romantic stuff. They gave him depth.
Mizuki's reason for going in the Jap version much better too. I love the whole tie in with Sano. In the Jap version I cared about the characters, I cried when Mizuki said all her good byes. Granted it wasn't true to the manga, but at lest it still gave you the feel of the manga. The Twa version was to slap-stick to ever be sentimental and heart felt.

Any way think the special will focus more on the romantic side of it, and bring more of the manga into it. I hope

[izumi1925]

Personally, I liked the taiwanese version of Hana Kimi better mostly because I'm baised. I had heard of it first and I'm a big fahrenheit fan (especially Jiro).

I love the taiwanese version of It Started With A Kiss! Much better than the jap version. But that isn't biased, cause it was the first TDrama I watched and I was into jap stuff at the time.

[MistressMacki]

I was disappointed with the TW ending, too. There was supposed to be a second season, but then the producer decided to let the viewers decide for themselves what happened or something. I was extremely put out when I found out the second season wasn't going to happen.

[MistressMacki]

Originally Posted by haruka.hayase

I prefer the J version too more funny and nature also lot of handsome guys especially Shirota Yuu as Kagurazaka

Guh...I HATED him as Kagurazaka. He was too mellow, too quiet and such, he didn't fit the part at all! I like Shirota, but...Kagurazaka needs a better actor for him.