[dizeo]

It would be unrasonal or cruel to kill Al because all the adventure start with ED wanting to get back his brother body. To tell the true Ed could had live very well without his arm and leg because he is a genius, has cool mecanical equipment and he have winly how is xcrasy for him. The most posible end would be that Ed dies or goes to the real world or it has happy ending, But Al yes or yes has to get his body back and the country has to be saved.

[Kurisuta1]

I think there a good possiblity that Ed will not get his limbs back.
Kinda selfish anyway seeing as tons of people loose their arms and legs in war and things when Ed lost his as a toll for a sin. Al definatly has to get his body back but Ed will be just fine the way he is.
Plus he didn't even want his arm and leg back in the first place, he just got the automail to get his brothers body back and just says he'll get his orginal body back cause Al tells him he has to, too.
So yeah...

[Kurisuta1]

Originally Posted by wutthecrud07

Hughes. =(

Hey, who is that on your icon? Is that Haru from I.S.? Kind looks like it could be Haru, but if its not sorry

[TrisakAminawn]

Hmmm...technically it shouldn't be labelled tragedy, since it hasn't given any strong indications that it's going to terminate with 'most everybody dead.' It has got pathos, though, and yes, there are a lot of tragedies stuffed into it: Trishas, Maes, Nina, Greed-tachi, Ishbal, Hohenheim. But I think the reason that all that sorrow got it the 'tragedy' tag is the sense of impotence. Ed can't solve it all. Ed can hardly solve anything. The problem is complicated and the enemy is all but invincible and is the master of the land. Ed rarely gives in to it, but compared to most 'fighting manga' (and I swear I don't know how it keeps that label) it's thick with futility.

And 'it's all futile' is what makes much of the sense of tragedy, so that's probably what the labellers were responding to. Or maybe just all the sorrow. Or maybe the way the anime ended. But not to worry, RulesChick, the people attaching the label know no more of the manga ending than you.

[FMAFangirl]

no offence but i dont like huges and was very happy that he died i think it wout be funny for riza or somthin to die O.o why am saying this riza is my fav character lol

[Beth732]

Originally Posted by TrisakAminawn

Hmmm...technically it shouldn't be labelled tragedy, since it hasn't given any strong indications that it's going to terminate with 'most everybody dead.' It has got pathos, though, and yes, there are a lot of tragedies stuffed into it: Trishas, Maes, Nina, Greed-tachi, Ishbal, Hohenheim. But I think the reason that all that sorrow got it the 'tragedy' tag is the sense of impotence. Ed can't solve it all. Ed can hardly solve anything. The problem is complicated and the enemy is all but invincible and is the master of the land. Ed rarely gives in to it, but compared to most 'fighting manga' (and I swear I don't know how it keeps that label) it's thick with futility.

And 'it's all futile' is what makes much of the sense of tragedy, so that's probably what the labellers were responding to. Or maybe just all the sorrow. Or maybe the way the anime ended. But not to worry, RulesChick, the people attaching the label know no more of the manga ending than you.

I like Eds quote 'i couldn't even save a little girl' (i think that's it) but what you've got to realise is ed's only human. It's hard for anybody to save anybody in this world really. Day after day, everyone including you is at risk and there's nothing we can do about it. People die, people live. Sometimes you just cant save people.

[TrisakAminawn]

Yeah. Tragic, no?

[Qvarg]

Originally Posted by FMAFangirl

no offence but i dont like huges and was very happy that he died i think it wout be funny for riza or somthin to die O.o why am saying this riza is my fav character lol

Whaaat? DDD: He's awesome Dx [/fangirl]
I don't want Riza to die either. She has always been one of my favorite characters <3

[Kakkoi]

Originally Posted by Kurisuta1

Hey, who is that on your icon? Is that Haru from I.S.? Kind looks like it could be Haru, but if its not sorry

Um i dunno what I.S is but the person on their icon is Haruhi from Ouran High School Host Club. Read it! It's funny.

[Kakkoi]

Shakespeare once said, "There is two ways to end a play: A wedding or a funeral. Comedies will always end in a wedding and a tragedy will always end in a funeral." How many weddings have you seen in this manga?

Although I really hope that Ed and Winry get married. They love each other. I know it. You know it. Hiromu Arakawa knows it. We all know it! Hell, I think the characters know it too.