[blueberrysaucenumber2]

if u were to choose between whos past was the saddest, who would it be? [ between luffy, sanji, zoro, nami, robin, chopper, and brook?]

mine would be....*cough cough* -not really sure x33-

[ravstrike]

probably brooke since he's suffered the longest by far... that ship's crew must run on prozac.

[Pezz Talent]

Nami or Robin. Nami because she watched as her mother was killed and then was forced to work for the pirates that killed her to save her village, who then even when they knew forced themselves to be mean to her, so she felt isolated from the ones she loved. And Robin because she didn't get to see her mother that much and all of her friends and family were killed. Then whenever she became friends with someone they either rejected and abandoned her or were killed.

[SH crew]

I would say brooke because he had to watch his crew die right in front of him. And then live alone until Luffy came along. I feel bad for the guy

[chenvoy]

The top two saddest are Brookes and Robin's.

For third, I might say Chopper, becuase of the coincedince of him eating the human human fruit, his pack disowned him, and they were already mean to him for his bluea nose. Also Chopper poisined his father in a way, Dr.H, after trying so hard to get him a cure.

[kuronagareboshi]

I would say Robin, nami, or brooke. Except i dont really know about brooke all that much, but yknow being alone for however many years as a skeleton would be horrible...

[Loki]

Let's rank the saddest

1. Nami ---> She believe that she can save her village and with that tiny hope she started stealing from pirates against her will for 8 years and was devastated when she was betrayed by Arlong. She was living alone and was alienated from all the people she loves.
1. Robin---> Living alone since she was a kid and never had the chance of happiness even once...Also alienated from people because of her Devil fruit ability. Got traumatized after witnessing the devastating buster call that wipe out ohara and all the people she knows. Live with fear and trusting no one.
2. Franky ---> Was abandoned when he was a child and grew from the care of Tom. The weapon he made was the one that causes his beloved tom to be executed.
2. Chopper---> No one wants to accept him other than Dr. Hiluluk but when he finally found someone who cares for him, Dr. Hiluluk just have to die and the reason is because of his action.
3. Brooke --->
4. Usopp --->
5. Sanji --->
6. Zoro --->
7. Luffy --->

[Gear2Luffy]

Mine are:


1. brooke

2. robin

3. franky

4. chopper

5. sanji

6. nami

7. usopp

8. zoro

9. luffy

[conanfan3344]

I just feel like it justs keep getting sadder and sadder and each new members join but I think my top would be either Nami or Robin

[Gear2Luffy]

Originally Posted by conanfan3344

I just feel like it justs keep getting sadder and sadder and each new members join but I think my top would be either Nami or Robin

you might be right, it is becoming sadder with every new member