[motmot]

when it comes to near death experience they both has silly smile (but roger's still executed)

[crackspider]

Originally Posted by CrazyChild

I don't think it's a replay, cause Roger must have had it much easier cause there were nearly none other pirates worth being called so since the Pirate age started after his death and at least one of the Yonkou (Shanks) was part of his crew...

no the "great pirate age" started after Gol.D Rogers death there were pirates before then but it wasnt such a big dream.
also the fact about will of D having the same motives no not true cos luffys dream is to get one piece while roger actualy collected one piece thru sheer effort
the main similaritys would be that they might share the same liniege (be related in some random and awkuard way) like luffy and ace are.
and that they both when they died or in luffys case nearly died on the execution stand they smiled (i think death might have made a funny joke)

[chenvoy]

You guys remember after ACE lost to blackbeard, they said that this will set start some kind of new age ..... I think that there will be a point in One piece were the same events that happened during Gold D.'s time will happen to luffy and them. Becuase a lot of similiarities have just been brought up to then and now of the pirate age. And from these events it could lead to someone's death or finding OnePiece.

[Tony My Chopping]

They two has a same goal... But I think, they have a similar smile

[Son Goku]

Originally Posted by Tekomaru

Basically i don't think he had actually eaten a Devil's Fruit and i also believe that Shanks got his Chivalry about being a pirate(if u eat a devil's fruit, u won't be able to swim and so on) from him
And one last thing that just crossed my mind:
Does any of you think that Luffy and Coby's Relationship is Similar to Roger's and Garp's?
One chasing the other... Whitebeard's words(Roger Garp Sengoku a few of them that knew the seas back in the day remain)And the Water 7 people's words(isn't that the great Marine that confronted Gold Roger numerous times)
And since Helmeppo uses swords and Zoro uses swords i'd say that Zoro and Helmeppo could be like Whitebeard and Sengoku.
And one more thing: If there really is such a stunning similarity don't u think that Whitebeard was Roger's First Mate just like Zoro in Luffy's crew?

To sum up should all of this be true what we're watching/reading is just a replay of the past with new characters

No i don't think so. cause in anime they said that only Whitebeard was enough strong to fight against Roger, so it means that they were rivals. If they were in the same crew the world would kneels before them, and WG wouldn't catch Roger.
And I think that Luffy can be the reicarnation of Roger. Cause in some moments they act the same, and Luffy goes everywhere were Roger has gone.

[CrazyChild]

I just found another similarity: Luffy and Roger were both born in East Blue.

[Jknight26]

the one and only comparison that i think u need is the one in chapter99 page17 where smoker asked the sailor had he seen anyone laugh at the execution stake at rougetwon and the sailor replied no but smoker said there was only one gol d. roger he luffy had the same laugh need more proof roger was the last crew to go to skypiea, or laboon was also visited by rogers crew as well .

[Lu Bu]

well i want to add ussopp with his father, yassop. but his father already join shank's crew. may be ussopp grandfather

[crackspider]

but yassop at this point has no connection with roger at this point other then they are pirates and that shanks was part of rogers crew

[bobotatay]

Are They Really Connected???
Gold D. Roger >>> Monkey D. Luffy,.. i LOOK at their photos and they are LOOK ALIKE
Zeff "Red Leg" >>> Sanji " Black Leg"
Nico Olvia (Nico Robin's Mother) >>> Nico Robin
Shakky (Money Addict and Navigator) >>> Nami (Money Addict and Navigator)
Doctor Kureha >>> Doctor Chopper
Tom(ShipWright) >>> Cyborg Franky(ShipWright)



I am Just Wondering if these are Connected too,..

Silvers Rayleigh >>> Roronoa Zoro,.. First Member of the Straw hat and Roger Crew

Edward Newgate "White Beard" = The Person Who Match the Pirateking
>>> Ussop "Sogeking" The Person who battle Luffy for Going Merry ,..

?????????????????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????? >>> Brooke(Yami Yami Fruit User)

i am So Confused but,..
ITS OK IF YOU WON'T TELL,..
i will just wait it and FIND THE ANSWER,..